The Truth about Carnival Corporation’s sustainability claims
Many Carnival lines offer trips to the Arctic and Subarctic and are powered with the cheapest, dirtiest fossil fuel available for marine transportation, heavy fuel oil. Sometimes called residual oil, heavy fuel oil is the bottom-of-the-barrel, tar-like sludge left over after other petroleum products are made from crude. It is so dirty that on land, heavy fuel oil is classified as hazardous waste. If spilled in the cold, often inaccessible Arctic environment, it would be impossible to clean up.
When burned, heavy fuel oil releases enormous amounts of toxins, heavy metals, greenhouse gases, and soot (also called black carbon) into the atmosphere. This threatens human health and the health of the planet. Some studies attribute up to 400,000 annual deaths from lung and cardiovascular disease to ship engine exhaust!
In the Arctic and Subarctic, the soot that heavy fuel oil combustion generates in large quantities settles onto ice and darkens the surface. When that happens, the ice no longer reflects the heat from the sun as it once did. Instead, it absorbs it. That accelerates the rate of ice melt, quickly intensifying the effects of climate change in the region.
An analysis published in 2018 showed that Carnival Corporation-owned ships carried the largest amount of heavy fuel oil into the fragile ecosystem of the Arctic of any cruise line operator, with over 11 and a half million tonnes onboard. That is nearly three times the amount of the next highest operator! Researchers also attributed a staggering 14 million childhood asthma cases to acute exposure to ship exhaust every year.
We are asking Carnival to:
- Switch all of the cruise ships in their global fleet to low-sulfur diesel fuel, and immediately end the use and carriage as fuel of all heavy fuel oil and heavy fuel oil blends in the Arctic and Subarctic.
- Further, reduce black carbon pollution on all Carnival Corp. ships by installing diesel particulate filters on all vessels in their global fleet.
- Take the lead in developing and implementing clean shipping technologies that help power cruise ships without fossil fuels completely!
Kendra Ulrich, Senior Shipping Campaigner, firstname.lastname@example.org, 360-255-3555
Virginia Cleaveland, Press Secretary, email@example.com, 510-858-9902
Miami Cruise World Ballon Banner Unfurl
Miami Action Photos:
NYC Action Photos:
London Action Photos:
Seattle Action Photos:
Amsterdam Action Photos:
- International Maritime Organization makes progress on heavy fuel oil ban in Arctic waters (October 26, 2018)
- Indigenous leaders, environmental groups tell Carnival Corporation to stop polluting the Arctic (October 24, 2018)
- Airplane banner protesting Carnival’s climate pollution flies over Miami cruise terminal (September 20, 2018)
- Activists, tribes tell Carnival: Stop polluting the Arctic by burning one of the world’s dirtiest fossil fuels (September 15, 2018)
- International vigils in Seattle, Amsterdam draw attention to annual Arctic sea ice minimum day (September 6, 2018)
- Under the radar: How the cruise industry threatens the Arctic (July 25, 2018)
- International coalition wants Carnival to stop using heavy fuel oil on cruise ships in Arctic (July 9, 2018)
- Climate activists disrupt Carnival’s new ‘Horizon’ cruise ship in NYC with banner protest (May 24, 2018)
- Stand.earth, Clean Arctic Alliance hail IMO move to ban heavy fuel oil from Arctic shipping (April 13, 2018)
- Arctic and Heavy Fuel Oil (HFO): Learnings from the Sanchi Oil Tanker Disaster (February 2, 2018)